52


CHAPTER XVII.

ENTITLED SURAT AL BANI ISRAIL (THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL).

Revealed at Makkah.

INTRODUCTION.


By some writers this chapter is entitled The Night-Journey on account of the reference to that event in vers. 1 and 62. But the contents of the chapter justify the ordinary title of The Children of Israel.

The burden of this chapter is the sin of the Quraish in rejecting their Prophet. The dreadful character of this sin is illustrated by the history of those who had rejected the messengers of God in past ages, and especially by reference to the destruction of the holy city of Jerusalem, in consequence of the unbelief of the children of Israel. The people of Makkah are therefore warned by the example of these rebellious unbelievers. They are told that no city ever was destroyed until its people had rejected the prophet sent to them. The inference to be drawn is, that the destruction of Makkah is near at hand, unless its people repent and believe on their Prophet.

The character of the unbelief of the Quraish is evident from their demanding of Muhammad that he would perform certain miracles, which he confesses himself unable to perform ; from their hideous custom of killing their own daughters, while ascribing daughters to God; from their foolish idolatry; and from their rejection of the doctrine of the resurrection.

The tone of the whole chapter is moderate, yet showing earnest purpose on the part of the preacher of Makkah.

Probable Date of the Revetation.

The verses referring to the night-journey (vers. 1 and 62) must, of course, be placed subsequent to B.H. 1, though they cannot date


53

later than the Hijra. As for the bulk of the chapter, the following data will enable us to fix an approximate date of composition: (1) The exhortation in ver. 55 points to a period when Muhammad still hoped for the conversion of some of his townsmen; (2) the faith of certain Jews and Christians at Makkah, alluded to in vers. 108 and 109, points to a period somewhat removed from the Hijra; and (3) with this agrees the spirit attributed to the unbelieving Quraish, whose opposition is decided, but not as yet of a violent character. From this we conclude that most of the chapter belongs to a period preceding the Ban of the Hashimites, or the final break between Muhammad and the Quraish, say about B.H. 6, or the sixth year of Muhammad's mission. The passage from ver. 24 to ver. 41, however, must be referred to Madina, as the precepts concerning the duties of children to parents, of all to the poor and the orphan, &c., seem to point to a Muslim community with definite laws of its own, and not to a mixed company, as at Makkah previous to the Hijra. I would place this passage at about A.H. 3..

The conjectures of the commentators, which would place vers. 75-82 and 87 at Madina, seem to be mistaken. See notes on these verses below.

Principal Subjects.

God praised for the night-journey . . . 1
The law of Moses a direction to the Israelites .. . 2
Noah's gratitude commended to his posterity . . . 3
The double sin of Israel and its punishment .. . 4-8
The Quran a direction to both the faithful and the unbelievers... 9-11
Men inconsiderate in their prayers . . . 12
The night and day are signs to men . . . 13
Every man's fate bound about his neck . . . 14
God will give every man the record of his life at the judgment day . . . 14,15
No nation left without an apostle . . . 16
The cities destroyed which rejected their apostles ... 17,18
Rewards and punishments of the faithful and unbelieving... 19,21
Degrees of honour belong to the life to come ... 22
Men should worship only one God ... 23, 24
Kindness to be shown to parents, the poor, and the stranger ... 24-27
Extravagance forbidden . . . 28, 29
Those unable to contribute for the support of the poor may help them by speaking kindly to them. . . 30, 31
Stinginess and foolish extravagance forbidden . . . 32
Infanticide, fornication, and murder forbidden . . . 33-35
The murdered man to be avenged . . . 35


54

The substance of the orphan to be sacredly preserved .. . 36
Men should lead lives of honesty and humility .. . 37-40
God not to be dishonoured by idol-worship . .. 41
Angels not daughters of God . . . 42
Various warnings for the Quraish . . . 43
A plurality of gods would lead to rebellion in heaven . .. . 44, 45
All things praise God . . . 46
The Quraish are judicially blinded to the Quran. . .. 47-49
Muhammad called a madman . . . 50
'The Quraish reject the doctrine of the resurrection . .. 51-53
The dead when raised will fancy they have been dead but a little while . . .54
Idolaters and unbelievers to be mildly treated . . . 55, 56
Some prophets peculiarly favoured . . . 57
The false gods need divine protection . . . . 58, 59
Every city to be destroyed before the judgment-day . .. 60
Muhammad not allowed to work miracles because of the unbelief of former tribes . . .61
The night-journey and the Zakkum tree causes of contention...62
Iblis disobeys God, and is cursed in consequence. . .. 63, 64
He receives permission to delude men. . . . 65, 66
He shall have no power over God's servants. . . 67
God protects the merchant while on the sea. . . . 68
Idolaters forget their idols in times of danger . . . 69
They are ungrateful . . . 69,71
The special privileges of mankind . . . 72
In the judgment all shall be fairly judged . . . 73, 74
Muhammad almost seduced from Islam . . . 75-77
The unbelievers almost persuade Muhammad to leave them... 78, 79
Exhortation to prayer . . . 80 - 82
The truth of the Quran to be proclaimed . . . 83, 84
Man's perversity seen both in prosperity and adversity . The spirit created of God . . . . . . 86
Revelation (inspiration) a peculiar favour from God to Muhammad . . . 87-89
Men and genii could not produce a book like the Quran ... 90
Muhammad excuses his inability to work miracles . .. 91-95
Men appointed messengers for men and angels for angels ... 96-98
The dreadful fate of the idolaters at the resurrection . ..99, 100
God is able to raise the dead . . . 101
Man covetous even in respect to God's mercy . . . 102
The nine signs of Moses fail to convince Pharaoh ... 103, 104
Pharaoh destroyed . . . 105


55

The children of Israel succeed Pharaoh in his possession of the land of Egypt ...106
Why the Quran was revealed in parcels . . . 107
Some Jews and Christians believe on the Quran ... 108, 109
God and the Merciful the same . . . 110
God hath neither son nor partner . . . 111


IN THE NAME OF THE MOST MERCIFUL GOD.

FOURTH MANZIL.

FIFTEENTH SIPARA.

R 1/1.

(1) PRAISE be unto him who transported his servant by night from the sacred temple of Makkah to the farther temple of Jerusalem, the circuit of which we have blessed, that we might show some of our signs; for God is he who

(1) Who transported his servant . . . to the farther temple. "From whence he was carried through the seven heavens to the presence of God and brought back again to Makkah the same night."

"This journey of Muhammad to heaven is so well known that I may be pardoned if I omit the description of it. The English reader may find it in Dr. Prideaux's Life of Mohammed (p.43, &c.), and the learned in Abulfida (Life of Mahom., chap xix )whose annotator has corrected several mistakes in the relation of Dr. Prideaux, and in other writers.

"It is a dispute among the Muhammadan divines whether their Prophet's night-journey was really performed by him corporeally, or whether it was only a dream or a vision. Some think the whole was no more than a vision; and allege an express tradition of Muaviah, one of Muhammad's successors, to that purpose. Others suppose he was carried bodily to Jerusalem, but no farther; and that be ascended thence to heaven in spirit only. But the received opinion is, that it was no vision, but that he was actually transported in the body to his journey's end; and if any impossibility be objected, they think it a sufficient answer to say, that it might easily be effected by an omnipotent agent."- Sale, Baidhawi.

The celebrated night journey from Makkah to Jerusalem, and from there through the seven heavens up to the throne of God, is regarded by Muir, NoŽldeke, Bosworth Smith, and other writers, as simply a vision, on which tradition has brooded and hatched out the story as related by most orthodox Muslims. Sprenger, however, considers Muhammad to have been guilty of perpetrating "an unblushing forgery," saying, "he sold a description of the Temple of Jerusalem, which he may have obtained from books or oral information, to the best advantage." Some traditions favour the opinion that it was a vision while others point to the opinion that it was a bodily journey. There seems to me to be two questions involved here (i) Whether the night-journey was originally simply a vision?


56

heareth and seeth. (2) And we gave unto Moses the book of the law, and appointed the same to be a direction unto the children of Israel, commanded them, saying, Beware that ye take not any other patron besides me. (3) O posterity of those whom we carried in the ark with Noah: verily he was a grateful servant. (4) And we expressly declared unto the children of Israel in the book of the law, saying, Ye will surely commit evil in the earth twice, and ye will be elated with great insolence. (5) And when the punishment threatened for the first of those

(2) Whether Muhammad, in speaking of this visionary journey, did not represent it as a reality? I think the arguments of Muir versus Sprenger (Life of Mahomet vol. ii. p.222) prove the journey to have been in reality a vision ; but I do not think they satisfy all the conditions of the problem. For, if simply a vision, and if related as such by Muhammad, why should Omm Hani have "seized him by the mantle, and conjured him not to expose himself to the mockery and revilings of the unbelievers?" Why should the faithful have been staggered in their faith in their Prophet, had it been merely a dream? And, finally, why should Abu Baqr have declared his belief in the story of Muhammad, were it only a tale of a dream? It seems to me clear that Muhammad represented this journey as a reality; and, viewed in the light of the many palpable forgeries of the Quran we think Sprenger's judgment, in this case, on the whole well established. See also below on ver. 95.

The farther temple. This could only refer to the site of the Temple, or perhaps the Christian edifice erected in its place, which Muhammad thought to he the Jewish temple.

(2) Rodwell notes the incongruity of this verse with the preceding, and suggests a verse may have been lost, and that this ver. I has been placed at the head of the chapter because the night-journey is elsewhere alluded to in it. But such want of connection between the verses of the Quran is too common to excite wonder here.

(3) O posterity, &c. "The commentators are put to it to find out the connection of these words with the foregoing. Some think the accusative case is here p ut for the vocative, as I have translated it: and others interpret the words thus,' 'Take not for your patrons, besides me, the posterity of those,' &c., meaning, mortal men". - Sale.

(4) Ye will surely commit evil . . . twice. "Their first transgression was their rejecting the decisions of the law, their putting Isaiah to death, and their imprisoning of Jeremiah: and the second was their slaying of Zachariah and John the Baptist, and their imagining Jesus."- Sale, Baidhawi, Jalaluddin.

The commentators here give six instances of evil committed instead of two. The allusion may be to the two destructions of Jerusalem, by the Babylonians and the Romans. The next verse, compared with ver. 7, certainly points in this direction.


57

transgressions came to be executed, we sent against you our servants, endued with exceeding strength in war, and they searched the inner apartments of your houses; and the prediction became accomplished. (6) Afterwards we gave you the victory over them, in your turn, and we granted you increase of wealth and children, and we made you a more numerous people, saying, (7) If ye do well, ye will do well to your own souls; and if ye do evil, ye will do it unto the same. And when the punishment threatened for your latter transgression came to be executed, we sent enemies

(5) Our servants. "These were Jalut, or Goliah, and his forces; or Sennacherib, the Assyrian; or else Nebuchadnezzar, whom the Eastern writers call Bakhtanasr (which was, however, only his surname his true name being Gudarz, or Raham), the governor of Babylon under Lohorasp, king of Persia, who took Jerusalem, and destroyed the Temple."- Sale, Zamakhshari, Yahya.

(6) We gave you the victory. "'By permitting David to kill Goliah; or by the miraculous defeat of Sennacherib's army; or for that God put it into the heart of Bahman, the son of Isfandiyar, when he succeeded his grandfather, Lohorasp, to order Kiraish, or Cyrus, then governor of Babylon, to send home the Jews from their captivity, under the conduct of Daniel; which he accordingly did, and they prevailed against those whom Bakhtanasr had left in the land."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(7) We sent enemies, &c. "Some imagine the army meant in this place was that of Bakhtanasr; but others say the Persians conquered the Jews this second time by the arms of Gudarz (by whom they seem to intend Antiochus Epiphanes), one of the successors of Alexander at Babylon. It is related that the general in this expedition, entering the temple, saw blood bubbling up on the great altar, and asking the reason of it, the Jews told him it was the blood of a sacrifice which had not been accepted of God; to which he replied that they had not told him the truth, and ordered a thousand of them to be slain on the altar; but the blood not ceasing, he told them, that if they would not confess the truth, he would not spare one of them; whereupon, they acknowledged it was the blood of John; and the general said, 'Thus hath your Lord taken vengeance on you;' and then cried out O John, my Lord and thy Lord knoweth what hath befallen thy people for thy sake, wherefore, let thy blood stop, by God's permission, lest I leave not one of them alive;' upon which the blood immediately stopped."These are the explications of the commentators, wherein their ignorance in ancient history is sufficiently manifest; though perhaps Muhammad himself, in this latter passage, intended the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans."- Sale, Baidhawi, Yahya, Jalaluddin.


58

against you to afflict you, and to enter the temple, as they entered it the first time, and utterly to destroy that which they had Conquered. (8) Peradventure your LORD will have mercy on you hereafter: but if ye return to transgress a third time, we also will return to chastise you; and we have appointed hell to be the prison of the unbelievers. (9)Verily this Quran directeth unto the way which is most right, (10) and declareth unto the faithful, who do good works, that they shall receive a great reward; (11) and that for those who believe not in the life to come, we have prepared a grievous punishment.

R 2/2.

(12) Man prayeth for evil, as he prayeth for good; for man is hasty. (13) We have ordained the night and the day for two signs of our power; afterwards we blot out the sign of the night, and we cause the sign of the day to shine forth, that ye may endeavour to obtain plenty from your LORD by doing your business therein, and that ye may know the number of years, and the computation of time; and everything necessary have we explained by a

(8) We also will return to chastise you. "And this came accordingly to pass; for the Jews being again so wicked as to reject Muhammad and conspire against his life, God delivered them into his hands; and he exteriminated the tribe of Quraidha, and slew the chiefs of al Nadir, and obliged the rest of the Jewish tribes to pay tribute."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(12) Man prayeth for evil. "Out of ignorance, mistaking evil for good; or making wicked imprecations on himself and others, out of passion and impatience."-Sale.

Man is hasty. "Or inconsiderate, not weighing the consequence of what he asks.

It is said that the person here meant is Adam, who, when the breath of life was breathed into his nostrils, and had reached so far as his navel, though the lower part of his body was, as yet, but a piece of clay, must needs try to rise up, and got an ugly fall by the bargain. But others pretend the passage was revealed on the following occasion. Muhammad committed a certain captive to the charge of his wife, Sanda bint Zamaa, who, moved with compassion at the man's groans, unbound him, and let him escape upon which the Prophet, in the first motions of his anger; wished her hand might fall off; but immediately composing himself, said aloud, 'O God, I am but a man therefore turn my curse into a blessing.'"- Sale, Jalaluddin.


59

perspicuous explication. (14) The fate of every man have we bound about his neck; and we will produce unto him, on the day of resurrection, a book wherein his actions shall be recorded: it shall be offered him open, (15) and the angels shall say unto him, Read thy book; thine own soul will be a sufficient accountant against thee, this day. (16) He who shall be rightly directed shall be directed to the advantage only of his own soul; and he who shall err shall err only against the same: neither shall any laden soul be charged with the burden of another. We did not punish any people, until we had first sent an apostle to warn them. (17) And when we resolved to destroy a city, we commanded the inhabitants thereof, who live in affluence, to obey our apostle; but they acted corruptly therein: wherefore the sentence was justly pronounced against that city; and we destroyed it with an utter destruction.(18) And how many generations have we consumed since Noah? for thy LORD sufflciently knoweth and seeth the sins of his servants. (19) Whosoever chooseth this transitory life, we will bestow on him therein beforehand that which we please; on him, namely, whom we please: afterwards will we appoint him hell for his abode; he shall be thrown into the same to be scorched, covered with ignominy, and utterly rejected from mercy. (20) But whoso

(14) The fate, &c. "Literally, the bird, which is here used to signify a man's fortune or success; the Arabs, as well as the Greeks and Romans, taking omens from the flight of birds, which they supposed to portend good luck, if they flew from the left to the right, but if from the right to the left, the contrary ; the like judgment they also made when certain beasts passed before them."-Sale.

About his neck. "Like a collar, which he cannot by any means get off." See the Prelim. Disc., sect. iv. p.164.

This passage makes God the author of evil as well as of good. What man does he is obliged to do by his fate. If he will to do wrong, it is because his fate was bound like a collar about his neck, and which he was unable to loose. See chap. vii. 180, xv. 39-43, and xvi. 95.

(15) Read thy book. See Prelim. Disc., p.144.

(l6-l8) The effort of the Prophet here is to show that God would destroy the Arabs, and especially the Quraish of Makkah, just as he had destroyed the unbelievers in olden time.


60

ever chooseth the life to come, and directeth his endeavour towards the same, being also a true believer; the endeavour of these shall be acceptable unto God. (21) On all will we bestow the blessings of this life, both on these and on those, of the gift of thy LORD; for the gift of thy LORD shall not be denied unto any. (22) Behold, how we have caused some of them to surpass others in wealth and dignity: but the next life shall be more considerable in degrees of honour, and greater in excellence. (23) Set not up another god with the true GOD, lest thou sit down in disgrace, and destitute.

R 3/3.

(24) Thy LORD hath commanded that ye worship none besides him; and that ye show kindness unto your parents, whether the one of them, or both of them attain to old age with thee. Wherefore, say not unto them, Fie on you! neither reproach them, (25) but speak respectfully unto them, and submit to behave humbly towards them, out of tender affection, and say, O LORD, have mercy on them both, as they nursed me when I was little. (26)Your LORD well knoweth that which is in your souls; whether ye be men of integrity: (27) and he will be gracious unto those who sincerely return unto him. (28) And give unto him who is of kin to you his due, and also unto the poor, and the traveller. And waste not thy substance profusely: (29) for the profuse are brethren of the

(24) Show kindness unto your parents, &c. This command is on the whole well observed by Muslims. The respect shown to the grey head among them is one of their most pronounced virtues.

Say not . . . Fie. Use no contemptuous language towards them.

(25) Behave humbly &c. "Literally, lower the wing of humility, &c. - Sale.

(27) Sincerely return i.e., sincerely turn to him by repentance.

(28) Give . . . his due. " That is friendship and affection, and assistance in time of need."- Sale.

(29) The profuse are brethren of devils. "Prodigality and squandering away one's substance in folly or luxury being a very great sin. The Arabs were particularly guilty of extravagance in killing camels, and distributing them by lot, merely out of vanity and ostentation, which they are forbidden by this passage, and commanded to bestow what they could spare on their poor relations and other indigent people."- Sale Baidhawi.


61

devils: and the devil was ungrateful unto his LORD.(30) But if thou turn from them, in expectation of the mercy which thou hopest from thy LORD; at least, speak kindly unto them. (31) And let not thy hand be tied up thy neck; neither open it with an unbounded expansion, lest thou become worthy of reprehension, and be reduced to poverty. (32) Verily thy LORD will enlarge the store of whom he pleaseth, and will be sparing unto whom he pleaseth; for he knoweth and regardeth his servants. (33) Kill not your children for fear of being brought to want; we will provide for them and for you; verily the killing them is a great sin.

RUBA.

R 4/4.

(34) Draw not near unto fornication; for it is wicked ness and an evil way. (35) Neither slay the soul which GOD hath forbidden you to slay, unless for a just cause; and whosoever shall be slain unjustly, we have given his heir power to demand satisfaction; but let him not exceed the bounds of moderation in putting to death the murderer in too cruel a manner, or by revenging his friend's blood on any other than the person who killed him; since he

(30) If thou turn from them, &c. "That is, if thy present circumstances will not permit thee to assist others, defer thy charity till God shall grant thee better ability."- Sale.

(31) I.e., "be neither niggardly nor profuse, but observe the mean between the two extremes, wherein consists true liberality." - Sale, Baidhawi.

(33) Kill not your children. See notes on chap. vi. 137 and 151; also on chap. lxxxi. 8.

(35) Unless for a just cause. This verse is said (Hughes' Notes on Muhammadanism, p.140) to abrogate chap. ii. 178, though it is difficult to understand how a subsequent revelation can be abrogated by a former!

It is more reasonable to understand chap. ii. 178, which forbids retailation by private persons, as abrogating the law of this verse.

Sale says, "The crimes for which a man may justly be put to death are these: apostasy, adultery, and murder." See also chap. ii. 178.

We have given, his heir power, &c. "It being at the election of the heir or next of kin, either to take the life of the murderer or to accept of a fine in lieu of it."- Sale.

He is assisted. "Some refer the pronoun he to the person slain, for the avenging whose death this law was made; some to the heir, who has a right granted him to demand satisfaction for his friend's


62

is assisted by this law. (36) And meddle not with the substance of the orphan, unless it be to improve it, until he attain his age of strength: and perform your covenant; for the performance of your covenant shall be inquired into hereafter. (37) And give full measure, when you measure aught; and weigh with a just balance. This will be better, and more easy for determining every man's due. (38) And follow not that whereof thou hast no knowledge; for the hearing, and the sight, and the heart, every of these shall be examined at the last day. (39) Walk not proudly in the land, for thou canst not cleave the earth, neither shalt thou equal the mountains in stature. (40) All this is evil, and abominable in the sight of thy LORD. (41) These precepts are a part of the wisdom which thy LORD hath revealed unto thee. Set not up any other god as equal unto GOD, lest thou be cast into hell, reproved and rejected. (42) Hath your LORD preferably granted unto you sons, and taken for himself daughters from among the angels? Verily in asserting this ye utter a grievous saying.

R 5/5.

(43) And now have we used various arguments and repetitions in this Quran, that they may be warned: yet it only rendereth them more disposed to fly from the truth. (44) Say unto the idolaters, If there were other gods with him, as ye say, they would surely seek an occasion of making some attempt against the possessor of the throne:

blood; and others to him who shall be slain by the heir, if he carry his vengeance too far."- Sale, Yahya, Baidhawi.

(36) See notes on chap. iv. 2-5.

(38) That whereof thou hast no knowledge, i.e., "vain and uncertain opinions, which thou hast not good reason to believe true, or at least probable. Some interpret the words, Accuse not another of a crime whereof thou hast no knowledge; supposing they forbid the bearing false witness, or the spreading or giving credit to idle reports of others."- Sale, Baidhawi Zamakhshari.

(42) See notes on chap. xvi. 59-61.

(44) They would surely seek, &c., i.e., "they would in all probability contend with God for superiority, and endeavour to dethrone him, in the same manner as princes act with one another on earth."


63

(45) GOD forbid! and far, very far be that from him which they utter! (46) The seven heavens praise him and the earth, and all who are therein: neither is there anything which doth not celebrate his praise; but ye understand not their celebration thereof: he is gracious and merciful. (47) When thou readest the Quran, we place between thee and those who believe not in the life to come a dark veil; (48) and we put coverings over their hearts, lest they should understand it, and in their ears thickness of hearing. (49) And when thou makest mention, in repeating the Quran, of thy LORD only, they turn their backs, flying the doctrine of his unity. (50) We well know with what design they hearken, when they hearken unto thee, and when they privately discourse together: when the ungodly say, Ye follow no other than a madman. (51) Behold! what epithets they bestow on thee. But they are deceived; neither can they find any just occasion to reproach thee. (52) They also say, After we shall have become bones and dust, shall we surely be raised a new creature? (53) Answer, Be ye stones, or iron, or some creature more improbable in your opinions to be raised to life. But they will say, Who shall restore us to life? Answer, he who created you the first time: and they will wag their heads at thee, saying, When shall this be? Answer, Per-adventure it is nigh. (54) On that day shall GOD call you forth from your sepulchres, and ye shall obey, with cele-

(46) Seven heavens. These, according to the Jews, were, "the veil, the firmament, the clouds, the habitation, the abode, the fixed seat, and the arabath." See Weistein on 2 Cor. xii. 2.

(47 48) Compare 2 Cor. iii. 13-16.

(49) They turn their backs, &c. "Not allowing their gods to be his associates, nor praying their intercession with him." Sale.

(50) With what design they hearken, viz., "to mock and jest. One Nadhar Ibn Harith said, 'I don't know what Muhammad says.' Abu Sufian said, 'I believe some of his statements to be true.' Abu Jahal replied, 'He is a madman;' and Abul Lahab said, 'He is a juggler;' while some one else said, 'He is only a poet.' "- Tafsir-i-Raufi.

(54) With celebration of his praise. "The dead, says Baidhawi, call shall immediately arise, and shaking the dust off their heads, shall say, 'Praise be unto thee, O God.' "- Sale.


64

bration of his praise, and ye shall think that ye tarried but a little while.

R 6/6.

(55) Speak unto my servants, that they speak mildly unto the unbelievers, lest ye exasperate them; for Satan soweth discord among them, and Satan is a declared enemy unto man. (56) Your LORD well knoweth you; if he pleaseth, he will have mercy on you, or, if he pleaseth, he will punish you: and we have not sent thee to be a steward over them. (57) Thy LORD well knoweth all persons in heaven and on earth. We have bestowed peculiar favours on some of the prophets, preferably to others; and we gave unto David the psalms. (58) Say, Call upon those whom ye imagine to be gods besides him; yet they will not be able to free you from harm, or to turn it on others. (59) Those whom ye invoke do themselves desire to be admitted to a near conjunction with their LORD, striving which of them shall approach nearest unto him: they also hope for his mercy, and dread his punishment; for the

Tarried but a little white, viz., "in your graves, or in the world." - Sale.

(55) See chap. xvi. 126.

(56) He will punish you. "These words are designed as a pattern for the Muslims to follow in discoursing with the idolaters, by which they are taught to use soft and dubious expressions, and not to tell them directly that they are doomed to hell-fire ; which, besides the presumption in offering to determine the sentence of others, would only make them more irreconcilable enemies."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(57) Thy Lord well knoweth, &c. "And may choose whom he pleases for his ambassador. This is an answer to the objections of the Quraish that Muhammad was the orphan pupil of Abu Talib, and followed by a parcel of naked and hungry fellows."- Sale, Baidhawi.

We gave unto David the psalms. "Which were a greater honor to him than his kingdom; and wherein Muhammad and his people are foretold by these words, among others, 'The righteous shall inherit the earth.' "- Sale, Baidhawi.

Compare Psalm xxxvii. 29.

(59) Those whom ye invoke, &c. viz., "the angels and prophets who are the servants of God, as well as yourselves."- Sale. Rodwell thinks the passage alludes to Christian saint-worship, but this, like Sale's reference to the prophets, is doubtful. The allusion is very probably limited to the angels, who are called in ver. 42, "the daughters of God."


65

punishment of thy LORD is terrible. (60) There is no city but we will destroy the same before the day of resurrection, or we will punish it with a grievous punishment. This is written in the book of our eternal decrees. (61) Nothing hindered us from sending thee with miracles, except that the former nations have charged them with imposture. We gave unto the tribe of Thamud, at their demand, the she-camel visible to their sight: yet they dealt unjustly with her: and we send not a prophet with miracles, but to strike terror. (62) Remember when we said unto thee, Verily thy LORD encompasseth men by his knowledge and power. We have appointed the vision which we showed thee, and also the tree cursed in the

(61) Nothing hindered us, &c. This is perhaps the most decisive passage in the Quran to prove Muhammad did not possess the power of working miracles. He is said not to have received the power, and the reason is annexed - that former prophets bad wrought miracles, but had nevertheless been charged with imposture! The only miracle of the Quran is the Quran, which, according to Muhammad, was not his miracle, but God's miracle.

They dealt unjustly. See chap. vii. 74, and note.

But to strike terror. The purport of this saying is the same as that of the beginning of this verse. Miracles were always of a dreadful character, as the Flood, the destruction of Sodom, of Ad, of Thamud, &c. Ergo, were Muhammad to work a miracle, it would be one of terror and destruction to the Quraish !

(62) The vision. "Muhammad's journey to heaven is generally agreed to be intended in this place, which occasioned great heats and debates among his followers, till they were quieted by Abu Baqr's bearing testimony to the truth of it. The word vision, here used, is urged by those who take this journey to have been no more than a dream as a plain confirmation of their opinion. Some, however, suppose the vision meant in this passage was not the night-journey, but the dream Muhammad saw at al Hudaihiya, wherein he seemed to make his entrance into Makkah ; or that at Badr; or else a vision he had relating to the family of Ummaya, whom he saw mount his pulpit, and jump about in it like monkeys; upon which he said, 'This is their portion in this world, which they have gained by their -profession of Islam.' But if any of these latter expositions be true, the verse must have been revealed at Madina."- Sale, Baidhawi.

See Prelim. Disc., pp. 80 and 81; also note on chap. xlviii. 18, viii. 34, and above on ver. I.

The tree cursed im the Quran. "Called al Zakkum, which springs from the bottom of hell."- Sale. See also chap. xxxvii. 60.

"The zakkum is a thorny tree which grows in Arabia, and of


66

Quran, only for an occasion of dispute unto men, and to strike them with terror; but it shall cause them to transgress only the more enormously.

R 7/7.

(63) And remember when we said unto the angels, Worship Adam; and they all worshipped him except Iblis, who said, Shall I worship him whom thou hast created of clay? (64) And he said, What thinkest thou as to this man whom thou hast honoured above me? verily, if thou grant me respite until the day of resurrection, I will extirpate his offspring, except a few. (65) God answered, Be gone, I grant thee respite: but whosoever of them shall follow thee, hell shall surely be your reward; an ample reward for your demerits! (66) And entice to vanity such of them as thou canst, by thy voice; and assault them on all sides with thy horsemen and thy foot-men; and partake with them in their riches, and their children; and make them promises; (but the devil shall make them no other than deceitful promises; (67) as to my servants, thou shalt have no power over them; for thy LORD is a sufficient protector of those who trust in him. (68) It is your LORD who driveth forward the ships for you in the sea, that ye may seek to enrich yourselves of his abundance by commerce; for he is merciful towards you. (69) When a misfortune befalleth you at sea, the false deities whom ye invoke are forgotten by you, except him alone: yet when he bringeth you safe to dry land, ye

which the fruit is excessively bitter. It was no doubt this bad quality which induced Muhammad to place it in hell."- Savary.

(63-65) Iblis. See notes on chap. ii. 34, vii. 11-19, and xv. 28-44.

(66) Footmem, i.e., use every means in your power.

Partake with them in their riches, &c. "Instigating them to get wealth by unlawful means, and to spend it in supporting vice and superstition, and tempting them to incestuous mixtures, and to give their children names in honour of their idols, as Abd Yaguth, Abd al Uzza, &c."- Sale, Baidhawi.

Savary translates this passage, preserving the spirit of the original, thus :-" Render men docile to thy voice; attack them with thy legions ; increase their riches and the number of their children flatter them with delightful hopes. Thy promises shall be delusive."

(69) Man is ungrateful. See notes on chap. x. 23, 24.


67

retire afar off from him, and return to your idols; for man not cause the dry land to swallow you up, or that he will is ungrateful. (70) Are ye therefore secure that he will not send against you a whirlwind driving the sands to overwhelm you? Then shall ye find none to protect you. (71) Or are ye secure that he will not cause you again to commit yourselves to the sea another time, and send against you a tempestuous wind, and drown you; for that ye have been ungrateful? then shall ye find none to defend you against us in that distress. (72) And now have we honoured the children of Adam by sundry peculiar privaleges and endowments; and we have given them conveniences of carriage by land and by sea, and have provided food for them of good things; and we have preferred them before many of our creatures which we have created, by granting them great prerogatives.

R 8/8.

(73) On a certain day we will call all men to judgment with their respective leader: and whosoever shall have his book given him into his right hand, they shall read their book with joy and satisfaction; and they shall not be wronged a hair. (74) And whoever hath been blind in this life shall be also blind in the next, and shall wander more widely from the path of salvation. (75) It wanted little but the unbelievers had tempted thee

(73) Their ... leader. "Some interpret this of the prophet sent to every people; others, of the heads of sects; others, of the various religions professed in the world; others, of the books which shall be given to every man at the resurrection, containing a register of their good and bad actions."- Sale, Baidhawi.

Whosoever shall have his book, &c. See the Prelim. Disc., p. 144.

A hair. See note on chap. iv. 47.

(74) Blind, i.e., in respect to the truth of Islam.

(75) It wanted but little &c. "These are generally supposed to have been the tribe of Thakif; the inhabitants of al Tayif, who insisted on Muhammad's granting them several very extraordinary privileges, as the terms of their submission to him; for they demanded that they might be made free from the legal contribution of alms, and from observing the appointed times of prayer; that they might be allowed to keep their idol al Lat for a certain time (Prelim. Disc., p.39), and that their territory might be declared a place of security, and not be violated, like that of Makkah, &c. And


68

to swerve from the instructions which we had revealed unto thee, that thou shouldest devise concerning us a different thing; and then would they have taken thee for their friend: (76) and unless we had confirmed thee, thou hadst certainly been very near inclining unto them a little. (77) Then would we surely have caused thee to taste the punishment of life and the punishment of death; and thou shouldest not have found any to protect thee against us. (78) The unbelievers had likewise almost caused thee to depart the land, that they might have expelled thee thence: but then should they not have tarried therein

they added, that if the other Arabs asked him the reason of these concessions, he should say that God bad commanded him so to do. According to which explication it is plain this verse must have been revealed long after the Hijra.

"Some, however, will have the passage to have been revealed at Makkah, on occasion of the Quraish, who told Muhammad they would not suffer him to kiss the black stone in the wall of the Kaabah, unless he also visited their idols and touched them with his hand, to show his respect"

Muir refers this passage to the compromise which Muhammad made with idolatry at Makkah in the sixth year of his mission. Certainly the explanations of the commentators, as given by Sale, are, to say the least, very improbable. But the passage carries with it a definite meaning when applied to the "lapse of Muhammad." For the whole story, with the authorities of the same, the reader is referred to Muir's Life Of Mahomet, vol. ii. chap. v. ; see also notes on chap. xxii. 53, 54, and chap. liii. 19-23.

(77) The punishment of life and . . death, viz., "both of this life and the next. Some interpret the first of the punishment in the next world, and the latter of the torture of the sepulcher."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(78) Had likewise almost caused thee to depart, &c. "The commentators differ as to the place where this passage was delivered and the occasion of it. Some think it was revealed at Makkah, and that it refers to the violent enmity which the Quraish bore Muhammad, and their restless endeavours to make him leave Makkah, as he was at length obliged to do. But as the persons here spoken of seem not to have prevailed in their project, others suppose that the verse was revealed at Madina, on the following occasion: The Jews, envious of Muhammad's good reception and stay there, told him, by way of counsel, that Syria was the land of the prophets, and that if he was a prophet h e ought to go thither. Muhammad, seriously reflecting on what they had said, began to think they had advised him well and actually set out and proceeded a day's journey on his way to Syria; whereupon God acquainted him with their design by


69

after thee, except a little while. (79) This is the method of dealing which we have prescribed ourselves in respect to our apostles, whom we have already sent before thee: and thou shalt not find any change in our prescribed method.

R 9/9.

(80) Regularly perform thy prayer at the declension of the sun, at the first darkness of the night, and the prayer of daybreak; for the prayer of daybreak is borne

the revelation of this verse, and he returned to Madina. "- Sale, Baidhawi, Jalaluddin.

These interpretations of the commentators have a suspicious look here.. The first could only apply if shown that Muhammad ever did meditate leaving Makkah before the Hijra, which we have no reason to believe. The second is not only without historical basis, but in itself improbable. A better meaning is suggested by what follows: that, should he leave the unbelievers as he was tempted to do by their obstinate unbelief, the result would be speedy destruction to the unbelievers, as Lot's leaving Sodom had been the precursor of the divine vengeance on the Sodomites, or as Shuaib's departure from the Midianites was followed by a pestilent storm from heaven, &c. (see chap. vii. 81-94).

Except a little while. "This was fulfilled, according to the former of the above-mentioned explications, by the loss of the Quraish at Badr; and, according to the latter, by the great slaughter of the Jews of Quraidha and at Nadhir."- Sale.

This pretended fulfilment confutes the explications referred to by Sale above. The first contradicts the terms of the text, which plainly make the threatened punishment to depend upon their success in persuading Muhammad to leave Makkah. As they did not succeed, and the text implies that they did not, we must believe the threat never could have had a fulfilment. The same statement applies to the second explanation of the commentators, which implies, contrary to the purport of the text, that Muhammad actually left Madina.

(80) The declension of the sun, i.e., "at the time of noon-prayer, when the sun declines from the meridian; or, as some choose to translate the words, at the setting of the sun, which is the time of the first evening prayer. - Sale.

First darkness. "The time of the last evening prayer."- Sale.

Prayer of daybreak. "Literally, the reading of the daybreak; whence some suppose the reading of the Quran at that time is here meant."- Sale.

It seems clear from this passage that Muhammad first observed the Jewish hours of prayer.

Borne witness unto by the angels, viz., "the guardian angels, who, according to some, are relieved at that time; or else the angels appointed to make the change of night into day, &c."- Sale, Baidhawi.


70

witness unto by the angels. (81) And watch some part of the night in the same exercise, as a work of supererogation for thee: peradventure thy LORD will raise thee to an honourable station. (82) And say, O LORD, cause me to enter with a favourable entry, and cause me to come forth with a favourable coming forth; and grant me from thee an assisting power. (83) And say, Truth is come, and falsehood is vanished: for falsehood is of short continuance. (84) We send down of the Quran that which is a medicine and mercy unto the true believers; but it shall only increase the perdition of the unjust. (85) When we bestow favours on man, he retireth and withdraweth himself ungratefully from us: but when evil

(81) Watch some part of the night, &c. This suggests how the two hours of prayer added to the Jewish times of prayer had their rise. They were first supererogatory and afterwards were made necessary.

Thy Lord will raise thee, &c. "According to a tradition of Abu Huraira, the honourable station here intended is that of intercession for others."- Sale, Jalaluddin.

Rodwell thinks the station has reference to the nearness of the believer to God, attained in spiritual ecstasies, &c.

(82) Cause me to enter, &c. "That is, grant that I may enter my grave with peace, and come forth from it at the resurrection with honour and satisfaction. In which sense this petition is the same with that of Balaam, 'Let me die the death of the righteous, and let my last end be like his' (Numb. xxiii. 10).

"But as the person here spoken to is gene rally supposed to be Muhammad, the commentators say he was commanded to pray in these words for a safe departure from Makkah, and a good reception at Madina; or for a sure refuge in the cave, where he hid himself when he fled from Makkah; or, which is the more common opinion, for a victorious entrance into Makkah and a safe return thence."- Sale, Baidhawi, Jalaluddin.

(83) "These words Muhammad repeated when he entered the temple of Makkah after the taking of that city, and cleansed it of the idols; a great number of which are said to have fallen down on his touching them with the end of the stick he held in his hand."- Sale, Baidhawi, and Gagnier's Life of Mahomet, vol. ii. p.127.

The passage is closely connected with the preceding verse, which seems to show that both verses have been adapted by the commentators to various events which might be alluded to, the half-dozen or more events, to which the former part of this passage is made to apply (see Tafsir-i-Raufi, in loco), indicate that the application of fanciful. portion to the entry of Makkah is purely arbitrary and fanciful.


71

toucheth him, he despaireth of our mercy. (86) Say, Every one acteth after his own manner: but your LORD best knoweth who is most truly directed in his way.

R 10/10.

(87) They will ask thee concerning the spirit: answer, The spirit was created at the command of my LORD: but ye have no knowledge given unto you, except a little., (88) If we pleased, we should certainly take away that; which we have revealed unto thee: in such case thou couldst not find any to assist thee therein against us, (89) unless through mercy from thy LORD; for his favour towards thee hath been great. (90) Say, Verily if men and genii were purposely assembled, that they might produce a book like this Quran, they could not produce one

(86) Every one acteth after his own manner, i.e., according to his judgment or opinion, be it true or false; or according to the bent of his mind and the natural constitution of his body."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(87) The spirit, "or the soul of man. Some interpret it of the Angel Gabriel or of the divine revelation."- Sale.

Rodwell takes the latter view, and fills up the ellipsis by inserting the word proceedeth instead of was created. The Tafsir-i-Husaini, Tafsir-i-Raufi and the Commentary by Abdul Qadir all agree with Sale.

At the command, viz., "by the word Kun, i.e. Be; consisting of an immaterial substance and not generated like the body. But, according to a different opinion, this passage should be translated, 'The spirit is of those things, the knowledge of which thy Lord hath reserved to himself.' For it is said that the Jews bid the Quraish ask Muhammad to relate the history of those who slept in the cave (see next chapter), and of Dhu al Qarnain, and to give them an account of the soul of man; adding, that if he pretended to answer all the three questions, or could answer none of them, they might be sure he was no prophet; but if he gave an answer to one or two of the questions, and was silent as to the other, he was really a prophet. Accordingly, when they propounded the questions to him, he told them the two histories but acknowledged his ignorance as to the origin of the human soul. - Sale, Baidhawi.

Except a little. "All your knowledge being acquired from the information of your senses, which must necessarily fail you in spiritual speculations, without the assistance of divine revelation." - Sale, Baidhawi.

(88) That which we have revealed, viz., "the Quran, by razing it both from the written copies and the memories of men."- Sale.

This passage again sets forth Muhammad's belief in the inspiration of the Quran. According to the next verse he regarded himself as a special favourite of God.

(90) See notes on chap. ii. 23, vi.94, viii. 31, and x. 39.


72

like unto it, although the one of them assisted the other. (91) And we have variously propounded unto men in this Quran every kind of figurative argument; but the greater part of men refuse to receive it, merely out of infidelity. (92) And they say, We will by no means believe on thee until thou cause a spring of water to gush forth for us out of the earth; (93) or thou have a garden of palm-trees and vines, and thou cause rivers to spring forth from the midst thereof in abundance; (94) or thou cause the heaven to fall down upon us, as thou hast given out, in pieces; or thou bring down GOD and the angels to vouch for thee; (95) or thou have a house of gold; or thou ascend by a ladder to heaven: neither will we believe thy ascending thither alone, until thou cause a book to descend unto us, bearing witness of thee, which we may read. Answer, My LORD be praised Am I other than a man, sent as an apostle?

R 11/11.

(96) And nothing hindereth men from believing, when a direction is come unto them, except that they say, Hath GOD sent a man for his apostle? (97) Answer, If the angels had walked on earth as familiar inhabitants thereof, we had surely sent down unto them from heaven an angel for our apostle. (98) Say, GOD is a sufficient witness between me and you: for he knoweth and regardeth his servants. (99) Whom GOD shall direct, he shall be the rightly directed; and whom he shall cause to err, thou shalt find none to assist, besides him. And

(92-95) These miracles were demanded of Muhammad by the Quraish of Makkah, and though Muhammad here denies his inability to perform the wonders demanded, saying, "My Lord be praised ! Am I other than a man sent as an apostle?" and, not-withstanding the teaching of ver. 61 above, yet all orthodox Muslims believe on the testimony of tradition that he actually wrought all these wonders. See also notes on chap. xiii. 8 and 27.

(95) Neither will we believe thy ascending, &c. The allusion is to Muhammad's night-journey; see note on ver. I above. This passage proves beyond reasonable dispute that the night-journey was represented to the Quraish as a real journey and not as a vision. See note on ver. I..


73

we will gather them together on the day of resurrection, creeping on their faces, blind, and dumb, and deaf: their abode sha1l be hell; so often as the fire thereof shall be extinguished, we will rekindle a burning flame to torment them. (100) This shall be their reward, because they disbelieve in our signs, and say, When we shall have been reduced to bones and dust, shall we surely be raised new creatures?

NISF.

(101) Do they not perceive that GOD, who created the heavens and the earth, is able to create other bodies, like their present? And he hath appointed them a limited term; there is no doubt thereof: but the ungodly reject the truth, merely out of unbelief. (102) Say, If ye possessed the treasures of the mercy of my LORD, ye would surely refrain from using them, for fear of spending them; for man is covetous.

R 12/12.

(103) We heretofore gave unto Moses the power of working nine evident signs. And do thou ask the children

(99) We will gather, &c. See Prelim. Disc., pp.138-140.

So often as the fire, &c., i.e., "when the fire shall go out or abate for want of fuel after the consumption of the skins and flesh of the damned, we will add fresh vigour to the flames by giving them new bodies."- Sale.

See chap. iv. 54, and notes on chap. ii. 38.

(101) A limited term. "Of life or resurrection."- Sale.

The latter is probably the reference intended here. Compare chap. iii. 9 and note.

(102) For fear of spending them, i.e., "lest they should be exhausted."- Sale.

(103) Nine evident signs. "These were, the changing his rod into a serpent, the making his hand white and shining, the producing locusts, lice, frogs, and blood, the dividing of the Red Sea, the bringing water out of the rock, and the shaking of Mountains over the children of Israel. In lieu of the three last some reckon the inundation of the Nile, the blasting of the corn, and scarcity of the fruits of the earth. These words, however, are interpreted by others, not of nine miracles, but of nine commandments, which Moses gave his people, and were thus numbered up by Mohammed himself to a Jew, who asked him the question, viz., that they should not be guilty of idolatry, nor steal, nor commit adultery or murder, nor practise sorcery or usury, nor accuse an innocent man to take away his life, or a modest woman of whoredom, nor desert the army; to which he added the observing of the sab-


74

of Israel as to the story of Moses; when he came unto them, and Pharaoh said unto him, Verily, I esteemed thee, O Moses, to be deluded by sorcery. (104) Moses answered, Thou well knowest that none hath sent down these evident signs except the LORD of heaven and earth; and I surely esteem thee, O Pharaoh, a lost man. (105) Wherefore Pharaoh sought to drive them out of the land; but we drowned him and all those who were with him. (106) And we said unto the children of Israel, after his destruction, Dwell ye in the land: and when the promise of the next life shall come to be fulfilled, we will bring you both promiscuously to judgment. We have sent down the Quran with truth, and it hath descended with truth: and we have not sent thee otherwise than to be a bearer of good tidings and a denouncer of threats. (107) And we have divided the Quran, revealing it by parcels, that thou mightest read it unto men with deliberation: and we have sent it down, causing it to descend as occasion required. (108) Say, Whether ye believe therein, or do not believe, verily those who have been favoured with the knowledge of the scriptures which were revealed before it, when the same is rehearsed unto them, fall down on their faces, worshipping, and say, Our LORD be praised, for that the promise of our LORD is surely fulfilled! (109) and they fall down on their faces, weeping; and the hearing thereof increaseth their humility. (110)

bath, as a tenth commandment, but which peculiarly regarded the Jews; upon which answer, it is said, the Jew kissed the Prophet's hands and feet."- Sale, Baidhawi.

Ask the children of Israel. See note on chap. vi. 20.

"Some think these words are directed to Moses, who is hereby commanded to demand the children of Israel of Pharaoh, that he might let them go with him."- Sale, Baidhawi.

(106) Dwell ye in the land. The impression is left on the mind here that the land referred to by Muhammad was the land of the Pharaohs. See note on chap. vii. 137.

(107) We have divided the Quran, &c. See Prelim. Disc., p. 108.

(108) The persons alluded to here were Jews or Jewish convert; who either believed or pretended to believe in Muhammad as the promised Messiah. See note on chap. vi. 20.


75

Say, call upon GOD, or call on the Merciful: by which soever of the two names ye invoke him, it is equal; for he hath most excellent names. Pronounce not thy prayer aloud, neither pronounce it with too low a voice, but follow a middle way between these: (111) and say, Praise be unto GOD, who hath not begotten any child; who hath no partner in the kingdom, nor hath any to protect him from contempt: and magnify him by proclaiming his greatness.

(110) God or . . . the merciful. "The infidels bearing Muhammad say, O God, and O Merciful, imagined the Merciful was the name of a deity different from God and that he preached the worship of two, which occasioned this passage. See chap. vii. 181." - Sale.

Follow a middle way, &c. "Neither so loud that the infidels may overhear thee, and thence take occasion to blaspheme and scoff; nor so softly as not to be heard by the assistants. Some suppose that by the word prayer in this place is meant the reading of the Quran."- Sale.

Rodwell tells us this was in imitation of the practice of the Jews.

(111) Compare chap. iii. 39, v.19 and 79, and vi. 101.


Table of Contents
Answering Islam Home Page